NOTE:Here's where we begin to drive
toward the 21st
Century, with artists who grabbed onto Sinatra's coat-tails and hung on
for dear life. Some of these artists knew the Chairman of the
Board, while others learned of him through his music and became
converts to the cause of the Great American Songbook, with varying
degrees of success. From brash upstarts to ardent devotees,
you'll find who's who in carrying the torch in these latter days.
Steve
Lawrence and Eydie Gorme':
We Got
Us/Steve & Eydie Sing the Golden
Hits Jasmine Music 600 [CD];
Released August 6, 1996
1.
We Got Us
2. Side by Side
3. No Two People
4. Darn It, Baby, That's Love
5. Together (Wherever We Go)
6. Flattery
7. This Could Be the Start of Something Big
8. I Remember It Well
9. Baby, It's Cold Outside
10. Two Lost Souls
11. Harmony
12. Cheek to Cheek
13. I've Heard That Song Before
14. I'll Be With You in Apple Blossom Time
15. Green Eyes
16. I Hear a Rhapsody
17. And the Angels Sing
18. Who Wouldn't Love You?
19. Bei Mir Bist Du Schön
20. Marie
21. I Don't Want to Walk Without You
22. (I've Got a Gal In) Kalamazoo
23. White Christmas
24. Sentimental Journey
REVIEW: Before they devolved into
lounge-lizard heaven (and
there is a line that must be crossed), Steve Lawrence and Eydie Gorme'
were the Donny and Marie of pop music in the 1950s. And while
not generally associated with jazz stylings, these two albums from the
late fifties are given an extra punch by arranger Don Costa, who would
later mix it up with Sinatra. Eydie Gorme' has a bright,
brassy voice here, something which Doris Day would commandeer during
the 1960s, while Steve Lawrence has an eminently cheerful baritone
which mixes perfectly with Gorme's chipper stylings. It's all
so CUTE as they bounce off each other in prototypical duets like "No
Two People," "We Got Us," "Side By Side" and "Together (Wherever We
Go)" that you may need to lay off the ding-dongs and check your doctor
for diabetes warnings; but their pairing is undeniably winning, and
breathes a warm cuddliness which reeled me right in. Life was
all springtime and flowers when these two were singing, and all was
right with the world. Don Costa's arrangments are
penny-bright, with tempos which are right in the pocket, brassy when
the tempos begin to swing, and filled with technicolor strings on
softer sentiments. Steve Lawrence has a real talent to mimic
Sinatra's line readings, with a lazy ease to his singing which is as
precise as a stopwatch, and Eydie is with him note for note, sliding
sinuously on "I'll Be With You in Apple Blossom Time" while Steve waxes
rhapsodic on 'Green Eyes." The album occasionally sinks into
goofiness, as on the barely tolerable "Harmony" or the torpid
romaticism of "I Hear a Rhapsody." But overall this is an
extremely genial pair of albums, filled with an innately cheery nature
which most pop fans will count as a happy find. Check out more albums from
this pairsome as well - lots of hidden gems.
Bobby
Darin: Swingin' The Standards
Varese
Sarabande 6004 [CD];
Released May 11, 1999
1.
Don't Rain on My Parade
2. Breaking Point
3. It's Today
4. After You've Gone
5. Shadow of Your Smile
6. Other Half of Me
7. It's Only a Paper Moon
8. Talk to the Animals
9. I Believe in You
10. Lover, Come Back to Me
11. Liza (All the Clouds'll Roll Away)
12. Silver Dollar
13. Everybody Has the Right to Be Wrong
14. Try to Remember
15. I Will Wait for You
16. After Today
17. Cute
18. Mame
REVIEW:
Of
all the people who might be fingered as sons of Sinatra (in the musical
sense), few would've guessed that Bobby Darin, teen idol and singer of
such pop singles "Splish Splash" and "Dream Lover" would
become an heir to the Rat Pack's finger-snapping cadre. But
Darin's chameleonistic tendencies surprised many - and strangely, for
all his shufflings between genres (which included folk, rock, pop,
swing and country), it's for his Sinatra-leanings that he's
most celebrated today. This album, a collection of cuts from
various projects, is an ideal way to hear how adept Darin was as
putting on a tuxedo and stepping in front of a swing band. He
has a true talent for bending notes and hitting hard with
syncopation which other wanna-be's would ache to achieve.
Listen to the intense urgency of "Breaking Point," with it's harsh,
insistent rhythms, or the lounge-lizard emerge into the spotlight for
"Shadow of Your Smile," and you'll be impressed. The
album has a nice selection of both uptempo and ballad numbers, but
throughout each track, there is a keen sense of style - this isn't just
a suit that Darin's putting on for the public, he's very knowing about
these performances; he's got the knack to push these numbers out across
the spotlights which is much more than just a pose - he's that
good, and to hear him on "I Believe In You" (taken from the
Broadway show How To Succeed In Business Without Really
Trying) or the frenetic jazz of "Lover Come Back To Me" is
to hear an artist at the height of his powers. Not that every
number here works: the cover of "If I Could Talk To The
Animals" does little to raise it above the level of triteness, and
"Liza" sounds too chewed up by Darin's excessive mannerisms to be taken
seriously. But he almost channels Frank on "Try to Remember"
and throughout he's totally committed and totally convincing,
especially on my favorite track here, a bossa-nova take on "I Will Wait
for You" which is excellent. If you like this, (which I think
you will), check out more of his well-represented discography.
Harry
Connick Jr.: We Are In
Love
Sony Records 46146 [CD];
Released June 15, 1990
1.
We Are In Love
2. Only 'Cause I Don't Have You
3. Recipe For Love
4. Drifting
5. Forever, For Now
6. A Nightingale Sang In Berkeley Square
7. Heavenly
8. Just A Boy
9. I've Got A Great Idea
10. I'll Dream Of You Again
11. It's Alright With Me
12. Buried In Blue
REVIEW:
Herladed
in the early 1990s as the second coming of Frank Sinatra, Harry Connick
Jr. was seen as something of a child prodigy in his early years,
showing a remarkable ability at jazz piano stylings, and then later
revealing a distinctively flavored singing voice which was often
compared to Frank. But whereas Frank moved from strength to
strength, Connick has struggled to remain revelant, showing flashes of
brilliance on one album, only to fizzle out on another.
Connick has moved between New Orleans funk, jazz, pop and big band on
all his albums, but it's on this one which he adheres most closely to
Sinatra's model, blending time-worn classics with new compositions
which sound as if they could have been pulled from Cole Porter's
songbook. Recorded when Connick was just 22 years old, this
is a smart album, alternating between big-band arrangements and
smoke-filled room small combos, the album has a knowing wink in each of
the songs, which never quite allows the listener to believe that he's
listening to something from the 1940s. The bounce and bam of
"Recipe for Love" or the honey-hued lullabye of "Drifting" are all
hampered a bit by Connick's voice (his biggest liability), which is
both too nasal and too affected with a "New Yawk" accent to be
completely winning. But still, it's hard not to be charmed by
such street-corner doo-wop exercises as "Heavenly" or be swept up in
the Ravel-flavored "Just A Boy," or enjoy the slow shuffle of "I've Got
A Great Idea" or groove to the modern scat arrangements of
"It's Alright With Me." But I have a hard time
giving my whole heart to Connick; the music all feels
a bit "put on" and affected, rather than a true soul-deep love of the
genre he's steeped himself in. Other good choices from this
artist include: When My Heart Finds Christmas and Blue Light Red Light.
Michael
Buble: It's Time
Warner
Brothers/Reprise 48946 [CD];
Released February 8, 2005
1.
Feeling Good
2. A Foggy Day (In London Town)
3. You Don't Know Me
4. Quando, Quando, Quando - duet featuring Nelly Furtado
5. Home
6. Can't Buy Me Love
7. The More I See You
8. Save the Last Dance For Me
9. Try A Little Tenderness
10. How Sweet It Is
11. Song For You - featuring Chris Botti
12. I've Got You Under My Skin
13. You And I
REVIEW:
The
most promising artist of the early 21st Century might very well be
Michael Buble (pronounced boo-BLAY), whose self-declared affection for
the music of Frank Sinatra, Ella Fitzgerald and Elvis Presley has
created an intriguing blend of the three's styles; a hybrid that, to
me, is far more grounded than Harry Connick Jr's similar breakout in
the early 90s. On It's Time, Buble's
sophmore platter, the artist sounds ever more sure of himself as a
performer, no doubt helped by the touring and promotion of his debut album, and the songs and
arrangements, while similar to his previous album, are here even
slicker and more assured. Recording on Sinatra's old label
Reprise, the album blasts out of its gate with the down and dirty
"Feelin Good" which takes a hefty slab of New Orleans blues and ties it
with a confident vocal. The album has more than a few nods to
Frank, especially on the ultra-swingers "In Foggy London Town" and the
Riddle-take off "I've Got You Under My Skin," which, if anything, is a
little too close to Frank's version for its own good. But
it's not where Buble apes Frank where he succeeds; it's in striking out
his own territory, as on the silky duet "Quando Quando Quando" or even
on the straight-ahead pop terrain of "Home." He's
at his most revelatory on "Can't Buy Me Love" which takes the Beatles'
chestnut and swings it hard; or the buzz-saw bass that riffs on "The
More I See You." Buble has the ability to sound comfortable
on each song, whether it's the carribean swirl of "Save The Last Dance
For Me" and the be-bop arrangement of "How Sweet It Is (To Be Loved By
You)" - this is a confident, mature platter, and Mr. Buble shows
himself to be a formidable song-stylist who has the potential to go
far, he lacks only the mature world-weariness that comes with age, but
for a beginner, this album is startlingly fun and assured. A
first pick for Sinatra contender of the decade. Also, check
out his other
albums
, all of which show him to be growing and maturing as an artist.
Peter
Cincotti: Are You The One?
Concord
Records [CD];
Released March 11, 2003
1.
I Changed The Rules
2. Comes Love
3. Are You The One?
4. Sway
5. Miss Brown
6. Lovers, Secrets, Lies
7. Fool On the Hill/Nature Boy=20
8. Ain't Misbehavin'
9. Come Live Your Life With Me
10. Spinning Wheel
11. You Stepped Out of A Dream
12. Rainbow Connection
REVIEW: Of
the slew of hot young cabaret singers which have been popping
up in the early part of the 21st Century, Peter Cincotti is the
underdog; a nineteen-year-old sophmore at Columbia University,
his heavily-influenced jazz stylings, piano playing, and limited
vocals seem to be the second coming of Harry Connick
Jr. But on this, his debut disc, the minimilist approach to
the arrangements (consisting mostly of bass, drums, and piano) and his
thin, raspy voice, which reminds me most of a young Tony Bennett
(without the operatic power Bennett posesses), sound anemic compared to
more blatantly commercial outings by his peers. The album
showcases both his piano playing (most prominently on the skittish,
dispeptic cover of "Spinning Wheel") and his voice, which seems to be
an afterthought. The songs all have a distinct east-coast
flavor, and from beginning to end,
the album has a unity of sound and style
which unfortunately ends up feeling flat. There are times
this approach works well, as on the bleak, wintery "Come Live Your Life
With Me," which does exactly what it's supposed to do:
turn what should be a cheery sentiment upside down,
creating depth and meaning in what otherwise would be a
one-note recitation of love; or on the hiccuping lead-off
track "I Changed The Rules" which sounds like
something Frank could have chewed on with glee. But
other tracks fall far short, due mostly to clunky lyrics which stand
out like the proverbial sore thumb (it can't help that he wrote a
couple of songs with his mother) - most painfully on "Sway" which
lurches from ill-thought rhyme to ill-thought rhyme like a
drunken sailor. My hope for Cincotti is that
he'll find a producer who'll wean him away
from his bare-bones charts and lead him to a
respectable voice teacher to gather some power and flexibility
into his vocal instrument.
Tony
DeSare: Want You
Telarc 83620 [CD];
Released May
24, 2005
1.
Baby, Dream Your
Dream
2. Just In Time
3. Want You
4. Two For The Road
5. I Wish You Love
6. How I Will Say I Love You
7. Another Chance For My Heart
8. We've Got A World That Swings
9. Something's Gotta Give
10. (I'd Have It All) If I Had Drew - (from "My Date With
Drew")
11. Marry Me
12. Movin' On
13. Five Foot Two
REVIEW:
You've heard the
saying, "it never rains, but it pours"?
Well, according to the forecast, apparently the American
public is due for continuing showers of young jazz vocalists whose
colors all hue to the Sinatra side of town. Tony DeSare is
more of a jazz baby than some of the others, and his voice, while
unpolished, has a whispery quality that hearkens to Mel Torme's, but
DeSare is no mere vocalist - he's also a composer and accomplished
pianist, a la' Nat King Cole, albeit an Italian one.
The arrangements on this national debut disc are spare, usually with
just Tony and his piano, or occasionally with a tasteful jazz trio
backing him up, which is just as well, as DeSare's voice doesn't
contain much power - he's far better at creating a smoky barroom
flavor, or scatting both vocally and instrumentally in deft
jams. Still, there are moments when he's got Frank in his
veins, such as the nice 'n easy lead off track "Baby, Dream Your
Dream," and I could easily hear Frank tackle the original track
"Want You" with relish. He sounds most like Torme,
or a wounded Sinatra, on the dark blue "Two For The Road" which sounds
like it could be tailor made for Frank (how I would have loved to hear
Frank's take on these same songs - they're that good.)
Occasionally DeSare gets away from jazz and blues, and takes on
straight pop ballads, as on "How Will I Say I Love You" and "If I Had
Drew," but even these are low-key and piano-driven, and songs like
"We've Got A World That Swings" and "I Wish You Love" are
top-notch. The album only sags a bit with the more
questionable covers: "Something's Gotta Give" and "Just In Time" are
more novelty numbers than great choices from America's Songbook, and
while they're capably performed, the effect is more average than
eye-opening. Tony DeSare is an artist worth keeping an eye
on, and I suspect that if he continues in this genre, his voice will
strengthen, and his compositions will only grow more assured.
Matt Dusk: Two Shots
Decca
Records 260002 [CD];
Released June 15, 2004
1.
Two Shots of Happy, One Shot
of Sad
2. Miracle
3. Cold as Ice
4. Lonely Road
5. Theme From Loaded Gun
6. Don't Go Looking
7. Fly Me to the Moon
8. Please Please Me [Ash Howes Mix]
9. Precious Years
10. Always
11. Every Mother's Son
12. Five
13. Two Shots of Happy, One Shot of Sad [Hot Nugget Remix] [*]
REVIEW:
Of all the hot young studs
who are aching to jump on the Buble bandwagon, fellow Canadian Matt
Dusk easily has the best exposure, due to his
recurring appearances on the network television series Casino.
I mean, having national media exposure on a weekly basis didn't hurt
The Monkees, did it? Of course whenever you have a
stubble-chinned adonis making a record album, the thought immediately
appears: "should be modelling underwear, not singing" - but happily,
Mr. Dusk has the courage of his convictions and a modicum of talent in
the vocal department, and he appears highly at ease in singing this
kind of smoky bar-room material. I also like that much of the
material is original, rather than simply covers - I mean, the Great
American Songbook is great, but can't we produce any
more? Dusk impressively co-authors two of the songs here:
"Always" and "Five," and the album has a nicely modern sensibility in
it's arrangements which eschew the "Big Band" approach, but
unfortunately use too much synthesizer, which has the effect of dating
the sound - in a couple of years, (if not months) this production will
reek of the early 2000s. Some of the songs are very fine,
such as "Lonely Road" and the wonderfully titled "Two Shots of Happy
(One of Sad)" - I also get a kick out of the James Bond vibe found on
"Theme From Loaded Gun." The weakest links in the entire
album stems from the hip-hop vibe which intrudes on some arrangements,
especially the mis-thought "Fly Me To The Moon" and from Dusk's voice,
which sounds too reedy and flat - it lacks the raw punch of emotion
which these songs need to really sell them. Still, there is
much of interest here, and his soap-opera good looks and romantic
bent will appeal to his prodominently female fan base.
John Stevens: Red
Maverick
48937 [CD];
Released June 28, 2005
1.
Come Fly With Me
2. My Blue Heaven
3. Someone to Watch Over Me
4. Here, There and Everywhere
5. All of Me
6. This Love
7. I Only Have Eyes for You
8. Let's Fall in Love - Erika Christensen
9. It Had to Be You
10. Shadow of Your Smile
11. Don't Get Around Much Anymore
REVIEW:
John Stevens is a spawn of that vilifiable
phenomenon American Idol, which gave him the
national exposure he needed to be signed to Madonna's Maverick label
and put out this platter. But whereas most of the fodder who
appear on TV are shrieking divas, John Stevens is a child of Sinatra
and Co., which made him immediately anachronistic on Idol,
but conversely made him a darling of mothers everywhere, who took to
his fresh-faced young redhead and his old-school approach to
music. This album, titled Red (after
his hair color) is a fantastic debut - richly melodic, sung with great
sensitivity, (depsite his 17 years of age), and the songs, consisting
entirely of covers, is remarkably savvy in its selection.
John Stevens has a lovely baritone voice, a butterscotch swirl of Mel
Torme and Steve Lawrence, and despite his youth, his phrasing is very
easy and smooth. He struggles most in his lower
register, lacking power, which will come in time, as on "Come Fly With
Me." The arrangments, by Bob Mann are mostly unobtrusive to
the point of forgetfulness; John will need someone more talented in
this area to make his songs really shine; Sinatra always chose the best
arrangers for himself, knowing their power to make or break a song,
Stevens needs to gather the same for himself. But the album
is filled with lovely moments, from the surprisingly successful
re-molding of The Beatles' "Here There And Everywhere" into a solo
ballad, to the inclusion of Maroon 5's "This Love" - this album really
doesn't make a bad step in it's choice, although having Erika
Christensen duet with John brings nothing to "Let's Fall In Love",
since her voice is so thin and undistinguished as to bring the number
down a notch. I'm afraid that so promising a talent will be
lost without some punchier, more imaginative charts to break it into
the crossover market, but for now, this is an excellent debut - here's
hoping that Red will be the start of a long and
prosperous career.
Peter
Grant: New Vintage
Globe
Records/Universal Music
9877257 [CD];
Released May 25, 2006
1. Joanna
2. Walk Away
3. Best Is Yet To Come
4. Windmills Of Your Mind
5. Spooky
6. Fool On The Hill
7. Girl From Ipanema
8. We've Only Just Begun
9. I Saw Her Standing There
10. More I See You
11. You're The First, The Last, My Everything
12. Didn't We
13. On Days Like These
14. All The Way
REVIEW:
Out of Great Britain comes the newest crooner who has decided to take
his cue from Sinatra and Co. Peter Grant has both the singing
chops and the charisma to pull off the hat trick of sounding, well, if
not exactly Frank Sinatra, then a really good imitation of Matt
Munro. According to Peter's website,
he's
been singing in bars since the age of 13, and in the five years since,
has developed a canny repartee with old-school swing and smoky
ballads. His debut album, New Vintage,
is a smart mix of new and old, but all of it is arranged in classy
homages to the sound of the 1950s with small flourishes of horns and
strings tied sweetly together with discreet modern touches to bring the
entire package into the 21st Century. I can easily imagine
Frank's voice resting comfortably within these grooves, which manage to
capture not just the flavor, but something of the essence of those
times as well. Grant's voice is a powerfully honeyed
baritone, which can belt out the high notes of "You're The First, The
Last, My Everything" or stir echoes of dim-lit saloons on "The
Windmills Of My Mind." From beginning to end this album
manages to hit spot on the tone of timeless reverence for fine
songcraft, and even though the songs are from decades apart (everything
from The Beatles and Jobim to The Carpenters and more), each song feels
right at home with Peter's rich vocals pinning them down.
This is powerful stuff. Although I felt some trepidation
after seeing songs like "Spooky" and "I Saw Her Standing There" on the
tracklist, but no worries - even these seeming anachronistic songs get
cut into the whole cloth of the production, and sound
renewed. Peter could easily be Britain's answer to
Michael Buble, and if his debut is any indication, the best is yet to
come. Available only as a British import, this artist is
nevertheless worth checking out.
Frank
Sinatra Jr.: That Face
Rhino/WEA 70017
[CD];
Released
June 6, 2006
1. That Face
2. (I'm Afraid) The Masquerade Is Over
3. Feeling Good
4. I Was A Fool (To Let You Go)
5. Spice
6. Girl Talk -- Duet With Steve Tyrell
7. Cry Me A River
8. What A Difference A Day Made
9. You'll Never Know
10. Softly As In a Morning Sunrise
11. Trouble With Hello Is Goodbye
12. Walking Happy
13. The People That You Never Get To Love
REVIEW:
Although Frank Jr. has been getting good reviews for this, his first
album in many years, to my ears, it's something of a moot
point. Unlike sister Nancy, Frank Sinatra Jr. never really
had a career that was far divorced from his father's; and on That
Face!, Junior completes the transition from
hanging onto the coattails of his dad into a full-fledged tribute
artist, with the songs, charts, and attitude ripped right out of the
lounge-lizard mould of the 1960s. He even looks like Frank
Sr. on the cover, and it's not until you give the album a good hard
listen that you hear that this Sinatra is only an echo, not the real
deal. But that's not to say that this album is embarrassing,
or devoid of nice moments; Frank Jr. has developed a nice easy phrasing
to his delivery which, if not a match for his father's, is at least as
accomplished as any other of the numbers of similar artists.
But vocally, Frank is struggling at bit. Unlike his father,
whose vocals seemed to deepen and gain more power as he got older,
Sinatra Jr. sounds thinner, and at 62, the flexibility and range of his
voice is starting to ebb. On some of the songs, like "Feeling
Good" his straining to hit the high notes is shrill and painful, and
later, on "Spice" he goes noticably out of tune on one of the
decending lines. On the smarmy "Girl Talk" - a duet with
another Sinatra wanna-be, Steve Tyrell - the two decend into the roles
of leering old men, but sugared with a chummy camraderie that feels
stale. The charts are brassy and fine, with a swell intimacy
that fits Frank's vocals to a "t", but after listening to this album,
with its pale, somewhat bloodless singing, I wanted to hear the depth
of pathos and pain that Sinatra Sr. could bring to a song.
Older fans may enjoy this tangible link to the original Frank, but for
my tastes, That Face! feels a bit like leftovers.
Russell
Watson: The Voice Russell Watson - That's Life
Univsersal
Classics 4758517[CD];
Released March 8, 2007
1.
That's Life
2. Strangers in the Night
3. When I Fall in Love
4. You Don't Know Me
5. You Make Me Feel So Young
6. Born Free
7. I Left My Heart in San Francisco
8. Summer Wind
9. Let There Be Love
10. Smile
11. It Was a Very Good Year
12. To All the Girls I've Loved Before
REVIEW:
Yet another
tribute - or perhaps 'homage' artist from the other side of the pond,
Russell Watson' s debut ranges more widely than some other Sinatra
wanna-be's, dipping his toes into Tony Bennett's catalog, as well as
Julio Iglesias. But the bulk of the album is taken from
Frank's catalog, and if you can get over the appalling use of Frank's
Capitol-era signature "The Voice" on the album's front, you may find
some things here to enjoy. Russell's phrasing is certainly
more accomplished than some other debuts, something which can be
attributed to his having a few more years under his belt than his
contemporaries. But it still feels way too early for him to
be tackling an anthem like "That's Life" or even "Strangers In The
Night" - both of which call for far more life-experience than Mr.
Watson can claim to have earned. But his take on "When I Fall
In Love" is marvellous, with immaculate phrasing, and a soft burr
brought to his voice that fits the smoky mood of the song perfectly.
This smoothness continues on "You Don't Know Me" - and it's
clear that despite his shortcomings on the big, declarative songs that
pepper the album, Russell clearly has the chops to sell a romantic
ballad with more than the usual dose of youthful earnestness.
But his acquittal on these songs, only brings out his
shortcomings on other songs - when he tries to go 'older' such as on
"You Make Me Feel So Young" - well, he IS young, so it makes the song a
tad ridiculous - plus, Russell's voice tends to spread a bit on the
swingers, with a noticeable vibrato and British accent jarring to my
ears. Still, he swings well, unlike other youthful
singers, he's able to inject a bit of depth into the songs.
Since I wasn't familiar with him before this album, I was
surprised to learn that Mr. Watson is a classicly trained singer, whose
previous albums are different animals entirely - but having heard him
dip his toe into the Great American Songbook, I look forward to a
return visit. But please, let the world-weary songs keep for
another decade, at least, before tackling them again.
Ray
Quinn: Ray Quinn
BMG International 88697068192 [CD];
Released March 15, 2007
1.
Ain't That a Kick in the Head
2. Fly Me to the Moon
3. My Way
4. That's Life
5. Mack the Knife
6. Smile
7. Way You Look Tonight
8. Summer Wind
9. What a Wonderful World
10. Mr. Bojangles
11. New York, New York
REVIEW:
The
British version of an American Idol winner - and signed by the same
acid-tongued Simon Crowell - I expected both more - and less - than the
second coming of Michael Buble'. Unfortunately, Ray Quinn's
debut
is something notably less than other steller debuts. Despite
his
self-proclaimed affinity for all things Rat Pack, this album, which is
a carbon-copied blueprint of Frank's Reprise-era recordings, shows all
the immaturity and weightless heft that Quinn can muster.
Don't
get me wrong - he's got a fine tenor voice, light and sincere, but the
big problem with the album is the songs he's chosen to cover - with his
featherweight voice, he'd have been wise to lift songs from early in
Frank's career; the soothing ballads and swing-free elements found in
the Columbia Years catalog. Instead, Quinn has loaded his debut with
songs from a world-weary later-years Sinatra that the singer simply
can't deliver on. He sounds faintly ludicrous singing jaded
anthems such as "My Way", "That's Life" and "Ain't That A Kick in the
Head" with all the gravitas of a pious choir boy. And despite
his
affection for swing music, he hasn't developed the hard, cynical touch
it takes to swing hard on tracks like "Fly Me To The Moon" and "Mack
The Knife" - he, like Frank, needed several more years of seasoning and
heartbreak before he is able to inject these songs with the hard-biting
experience they require to be transformed into something more than
youthful pablum. He does somewhat better on an interior trio:
"Smile," "The Way You Look Tonight" and "Summer Wind" are all more
attuned to his relative youth, but even on these songs, he sounds more
like a boy-band crooner than a romantic swain. The songs are
stripped of passion, which Frank brought to his songs with a capitol
"P" and the listener is left with the cold skimmings of what should've
been rich cream, considering the craft of the songs and the deft
arrangments we're given. In short, Quinn may have won popular
acclaim, but he's clearly out of his depth.
Peter
Grant: Traditional
Globe
Records/Universal[CD];
Released September 17, 2007
1. Traditional 2.
Let the
Good Times Roll. 3.
That's
Life 4.
Until You
Come Back To Me. 5.
On The
Beach 6.
You're
Worth it 7.
This
Guy's In Love 8.
You Don't
Know 9.
On and On 10.
Never
Too Far Away From A Song 11.
Edge Of
Blue 12.
September Song 13.
Happy
Together 14.
Traditional - Chuck Norman Remix (Bonus Track)
REVIEW:
I loved Peter
Grant's first album - it was a extraordinarily confident and polished
debut for the very young singer, who sounded as if he carried an old
soul inside him. On his sophomore effort, Traditional,
his voice is still
a powerhouse combine of expressiveness and control, but he's veered
away from songbook classics into hybrid neo-jazz, with hints of
everything from Spanish rhythms to Elvis Presley-style southern gospel
thrown into the mix, and to be honest, it doesn't sound nearly as
effortless and compelling as his debut. The album starts off
very strongly, with a rough-and-ready attitude that might have been
ripped off from Sinatra's Ring-a-Ding-Ding
album;
(and don't be confused, the "That's Life" that's included here
isn't Frank's version, it's an entirely new song, with a vocal riff
that's instantly memorable and with great interplay between the singer
and
the band). But the album begins to veer off course right
about the same time that the cover versions of other artists' songs
appear. Burt Bacharach's "This Guy's In Love" misses the
trembling insecurity of the original entirely, substituting the aching
earnestness with a smarmy lounge-lizard croon that is vocally smart,
but emotionally empty. And the inclusion of The Turtles'
"Happy Together" sounds near to campiness with his throaty baritone
trying to scale the shiny-pop of this hit single. But that's
not even the worst here - some brilliant exec thought it might be a
good idea to include the 70s staple "On and On" with a big-band swing
arrangement, and the results are an odd hybrid of two worlds that are
circling in different orbits. There are many good moments
here; "September Song" is gorgeous - simple and clean, as is the
ultra-romantic "On The Beach" which is a perfect mood-setter.
And
"Never Too Far Away From A Song" is classic, even referencing Frank in
the lyrics.
And the opening trio of songs are surprising and different -
melding old-school sounds with neat modern touches that successfully
update the sound into the new century; but the inclusion of too many
uncomfortably-fitting cover songs make Peter's second outing a mixed
bag. Still worth checking out - if anything, his talent
proves that despite missteps, Peter is still one of the best new young
artists out there.