NOTE: Books
about Sinatra in the late seventies and early eighties were mostly sad
affairs, with trashy paperbacks and coffee-table books proliferating,
but usually without a thought in their heads to share. A
couple of notable exceptions appeared, however, in the form of
Sinatra's 'own words' being compiled, as well as a wonderfully literate
book by John Rockwell, courtesy of Rolling Stone Press. There
were also disappointments, especially
from Sinatra's daughter, Nancy, who tried for the
first time to set the record straight.
Frank
Sinatra: Is This Man
Mafia?
by George Carpozi
Jr.; Manor Books, Inc., 376 p.
Released June, 1979
"The
sedate but sometimes sensational Wall Street Journal caught
up in breathless fashion with the news of an era past about Frank
Sinatra's indissoluble camraderie with the Mafia. That wasn't a singing
group by any stretch of the musical scale - unless one's imagery of
rhythm encompasses the notion that fortissimo bursts of a tommy gun
constitute some form of lyrical instrumentation. In a lead story on
page one of its August 19, 1968 edition, the Journal raked Sinatra in
the unkindest terms. To wit: "Ordinarily a man's friendships are
nobody's business but his own. But Mr. Sinatra once again is back in
public affairs - in politics, and Presidential politics at that."
...The Jouranl [sp] rehased [sp]
much of the accounts we've narrated in this text about Sinatra's
connections with Willie Moretti, Charles (Lucky) Luciano, the Fischetti
brothers, and Momo Giancana. ...The most revealing thing about the
story was mobster Willie Moretti's alleged attempt to intervene in
Frankie's divorce from Nancy." [pg 275]
REVIEW:
Before
Kitty Kelly got her claws into Sinatra, George Carpozi Jr. beat her to
the punch with this sleazy, desperately-conceived hatchet job so filled
with stilted prose, dumbbell metaphors and hearsay that it almost
self-destructs under the weight of its own pretensions. Tying
together every
single printed allegation of mob ties with Sinatra, this book isn't
simply content to examine Frank's relationships with known mafia
henchmen, but also feels the need to psychoanalize his affairs and
marriages, his outbursts against the media, and even dismisses his
initial success as having been 'bought' by the mafia. Without a shred
of first-hand information to back him up, the author simply steals the
information from second-hand sources, quoting magazines and newspapers
en masse; and yet, despite the full-out raping of other's works, he
still manages to amass an author's credit with his error-ridden,
mis-spelt, and over-heated prose. Mr. Carpozi tries desperately to
sound street-wise in his writing, but only ends up penning inane lines
like: "The bad days had dawned..." and "The cast comprised just Frankie
and Mia. The scene involved no supporting roles and no selected short
subjects. It didn't need them..." (What is it with the '...'s? They're
everywhere!) The book has the audacity to question the legitimacy of
Frank Sinatra Jr's kidnapping, suggesting it was all faked, spends
countless chapters hounding Sinatra and Ava Gardner's affair and
marriage, and in the end, leaves the reader as confused as when they
began. An almost cultishly bad exercise in writing, Is This Man Mafia?
at least
had the ability to make me laugh with its amaturish posturing.
Sinatra
by
Alan G. Frank; Leon Amiel Publisher, 176 p.
Released August 1, 1979
"In
order to succeed, it would appear that talent is helpful, as is
luck. But in many cases the seeds of failure are sown when
the performer is unable to meet the (minimal) requirements of the
cliche's of this profession. Even after success has been
achieved, entertainers are still seen - and publicised - in terms of
cliche'. The 'rising star' becomes the 'star' and, when that
over-used word loses its potency, he or she achieves the status of the
'superstar'. As each new superlative is brought into use, a
fresher and more powerful one has to be found, and the ultimate weapon
in a publicist's armoury is the phrase 'a legend in his/her own
lifetime', one of the most abused tags around." [from the
introduction, pg. 7]
REVIEW: One
of a slew of quick-buck books put out over the years, this
early coffee-table sized book is a forgettable entry in
Sinatra's bibliographical canon. Filled with innumerable
black-and-white photographs of Sinatra, some rare, others
common; all surrounded by text which seems to have been
patched together from several different sources, offering no
insight, poetry, or enlightenment about its subject, but dryly
expounding people/places/events with all the class of a paper
napkin. Not that it's a worthless book - the pictures are
generally very good; from early portraits of Sinatra as a child and
young man, to later shots of him in the studio performing live in
front of an audience which includes Sophia Loren; to
full-color spreads scattered throughout the book in meager doses, it a
great book to look at, although the flat paper doesn't do the
photos any justice. It's the writing where this book
really fails - I'm not sure who Alan Frank is,
although I've found another star bio he's written of Marlon
Brando, but his prose is pretty stale, throwing in random
quotes from Frank and others without offering sources, giving lifeless
expositions of events as if they're as interesting as a plate of
scramble eggs, and cutting vast swaths of generalities like:
"As time went by, Sinatra was successfully to experiment with
new arrangers and new orchestras, as well [as] adapting
his style and material to fit changing public tastes and, more
importantly, to allow for the toll that age and use was inevitably
taking on his voice" [pg 124]. About as exciting as reading a
college textbook, eh? Buyers should expect this kind of hack
work on books like these - quickly written, assembled and
sold on bargain tables to unsuspecting, or undiscerning
fans. You can buy Sinatra
cheap, but you get what you pay for.
Frank
Sinatra
by
John Howlett; Simon & Schuster, 176 p.
Released November, 1980
"'Nasty,
rude, inconsiderate, uncooperative and ungrateful', said Kendis Rocklin
in a Los Angeles Mirror News article on
Sinatra. but, unlike cover stories in Time
and Look magazines, Rocklin also gave prominence
in his article to the Sinatra that could be 'quietly generous and
considerate without even expecting thanks'. ...[J. Lee] Cobb had had a
heart attack in the summer of 1955 and he recalled later, 'Frank in his
typically unsentimental fashion, moved into my life... Frank flooded me
with books, flowers, delicacies. He kept telling me what fine
acting I still had ahead of me... He built an insulating wall around me
that shielded me from worry, tension and strain.' ...'After I
recovered,' said Cobb, 'our relationship tapered off until I hardly saw
him at all. He seemed to disappear as my need for him was
over.'" [pg. 92]
REVIEW: Another
fairly typical photo-biography from the early eighties, this
examination of Frank's life and career is distinguished by the
uncommonly even-handed and skilled writing of the author, who manages
to lay out the prime moments of Sinatra's life without judgement or
apparent bias. Filled with stock black and white photographs
thorughout, which have the good grace to match the eras the text is
covering, on first glance this book might not appear to be anything
special; but for beginners, it's ideal in its brevity, succinctness,
and professionalism. Cutting the chapters into small
chronological chunks, the book chronicles "The Early Years 1915-1939,"
"The Slow Way Up 1939-1942," "Out on the Rainbow 1942-1947," "The Fast
Way Down 1947," "Love and Disaster 1948-1952," "From Here To Eternity
1953-1954," "The Second Time Around 1954-1958," "The Tough Monkey
1958-1961," "The Thousand Days 1959-1962," "The Summit 1962-1971" and
"The Long Goodbye" which takes the reader up to the (then)
present. Also included are a detailed filmography
and discography which is, of course, pretty much out
date, but still contains lots of good information, including
songwriters, arrangers, track listings for the albums and
more. The author covers in good detail every major event and
controversy of Sinatra's life, using lots of quotes to support his
narration, and managing to keep an even balance between the more
sensational aspects of Sinatra's life and his successes. Not
much to look at, but again, a good, solid introduction to Frank's life
and times. Frank Sinatra
is worth picking up if you find it at a used book
shop.
Frank
Sinatra: Ol' Blue Eyes
by Norm
Goldstein/The Associated Press; Holt, Rinehart and Winston,
153 p.
Released 1982
"...Sinatra
agreed to meet the Commission in a private, secret session.
His lawyer claimed he had never been opposed to testifying, he'd only
objected to the atmosphere. Following his appearance,
Superior Court Judge Frank J. Kingfield dismissed the contempt
citations and the warrant. SIC chairman William F. Hyland
said Siantra had "cooperated fully."
Two years later, it was a House investigation in Washington.
A House Select Committee on Crime, headed by Florida's Claude Pepper,
was looking into mob influence in organized sports. Frank had
had an interest in Berkshire Downs, a racetrack in Hancock,
Massachusetts, which, at the time of the investigation, was no longer
in operation.
It was a drama worthy of the wide screen. And, once again,
Sinatra was the main attraction. [pg. 110]
REVIEW: Yet
another unremittingly dull,
cheaply-produced 'tribute' book to Frank Sinatra which, put
out soon after Sinatra's return from retirement, Ol' Blue Eyes
manages to
somehow take a remarkably fascinating public figure and say absolutely
nothing of interest about him. Norm Goldstein, in association
with The Associated Press, put together this thin
biography which does nothing but recount Frank's
career highs and lows with a sprinkling of tabloid gossip,
tied together with vast quanities of undocumented news
clippings used as corroboration. It's the worst kind of
yellow journalism, with the author barely making an appearance in the
text, instead allowing his numerous cribbed notes
and unremarkable stock photographs do the talking for
him. We have paragraph after paragraph
of Frank's films being reeled out like string cheese,
with no commentary save brief snippets of what
critics said at the time of release; facts and figures of how
much money Frank made for appearances and films; cold recitations
of what songs Frank sang at a certain event;
awards and accolades he received from
various U.S. Presidents, and, like above, bare-bones
recounting of the government's prying into Frank's purported
mob ties. Accompanying these dry-as-dust facts are
several flat black and white photos from the associated press files:
stock studio pictures promoting various films,
quickie-photo shots from various banquets and ceremonies Sinatra
attended, early 'Swoonatra'-era shots taken by paparazzi -
nothing special, and certainly nothing worth searching out, this
shamefully mis-labelled book is nothing more than a cheap attempt to
cash in on Sinatra's fame.
Frank
Sinatra: A Personal Portrait
by John
Frayn Turner; Midas Books (UK) / Hippocrene Books
Inc. (US); Seven Hills Books [reissue], 160 p.
Released 1983, Reissued 1998
"The
remarkable aspect of these sessions was his blend of ruthless
concentration and gay self-mockery. Apparently the
range of one song was causing him some profound thought.
Halfway through the first take, he broke off while actually on the
climactic line and emerged from the voice box waving his arms for the
orchestra to stop. To the studio in general he announced: 'I
can't even talk in that key!' Then as the clock pointed to
9.25 p.m., Frank drank a cup of coffee and exchanged a few friendly
words with the Canadian conductor Robert Franon. Then back to
work. This time he did a perfect take, and emerged from the
box beaming and commenting: 'See what you get when you keep good hours
and live a clean life?'' [pg. 114]
REVIEW: At
first, I wasn't sure if A Personal Portrait
was simply an earlier incarnation of Mr.
Turner's later
Sinatra bio, but upon comparison, I was suprised: the
author has written two completely separate and distinct biographies of
Sinatra. Unfortunately, for this first, early effort, the
author fails to bring any fresh perspective on Frank as a person or
performer, falling back onto stale adjectives which never seem to get
beyond 'great' or 'exciting,' and his overly-enthusiastic pro-Sinatra
bias leaks out at every event, turning the narrative into little more
than overt worship at the Shrine of Sinatra. In the prologue,
the author recounts how simply walking down the street one day, he
heard a Sinatra song being played out of a New York record store, and
relates: "I stood there
on the sidewalk utterly transfixed.
It marked one of those moments when a rare conjunction occurs of time,
space and sound." It may have been a
transporting moment for
the author, but having to read his blinder-on approach to Sinatra's
life is about as much fun as drowning in molasses. Taking a
year-by-year approach to Frank's life, the book plunges forward
with barely a glance at Frank's very human failings, instead
painting a picture of saintly benevolence, god-like talent, and
unfailing wisdom. There are some nice moments when the author
steers clear of the treacly prose and clearly relates a personal moment
with Frank, as above, but these instances are far too few.
Near the end of the book, the author begs the reader's forgiveness for
the indulgence of a personal concert review, and asks us to 'bear with
him for just a page," but by that point, I'd lugged about as much
gushy, one-sided praise as I could bear - this book is only for those
who choose to see only the good in Sinatra; but by doing so, the
audience blinds themselves to the very conflicts which made Frank such
a great interpreter of music, and in many regards, ignores his very
human weaknesses which make him all the more compelling as a whole man.
The
Frank Sinatra Scrapbook: His Life and Times in Words and Pictures
by Richard Peters; St. Martin's
Press, 158 p.
Released August 1, 1983
"Rhythmically,
Sinatra had improved exceptionally - previously, he had hinted, but
only hinted, at what was to come, with recordings such as 'The Birth of
the Blues', 'Bim Bam Baby', and 'Sweet Lorraine'. Now, on the
non-ballad numbers that had become as essential part of his in-person
and recording repertoire, he really swung. Or put another
way, his singing had become unquestionably jazz-orientated.
The vocal metamophosis was more easily discernable during his live
performances. Apart from the maturity and all-round
improvement in his singing, the shy nice-boy-next-door entertainer of
the 1940s had changed to one of a sharp, finger-snapping extrovert -
sometimes arrogant, more overtly sexual, more instantly communicative
to concert and club audiences of all types and ages."
[pg. 87]
REVIEW: This
oversize paperback book is a good, occasionally
surprising look at Sinatra's chronology, most notable for the
inclusion of the original "Sinatra Sessions" by Ed O'Brien and Scott P.
Sayers, which later was expanded into The Revised
Compleat Sinatra (reviewed
earlier on this site). The author
is an unabashed fan of Frank's, as the over-the-top
gushing introduction alerts the reader. The core of
the book is a year-by-year accounting of Frank's greatest achievements
and milestones, from his birth through January of 1982,
glossing over the more sordid events of Sinatra's life and highlighting
his triumphs; nothing new here. Following this is a
reproduction of a 1946 article by E.J. Kahn entitled "The Slaves Of
Sinatra" originally printed in The New Yorker (and
later included in his book, "The Voice") chronicling
Frank's early stardom. Next is a
one page examination of the bobbysoxer phenomenon; a page
documenting Frank's many psuedonyms given him by the fans and
the media ("The Lean Lark" and "The Swing Shift Caruso"); two
pages on the Rat Pack (with quotes taken from Richard Gehman's book); a
slang dictionary similar to the one found on this site; a selection of
quotations from Sinatra on several different subjects; a 1980
fan poll listing the top 25 Sinatra songs ("I've Got You Under
My Skin" is number one); an lengthy article by Stan Britt on
Sinatra's "Great Concerts;" a section of quotations from Sinatra's film
co-stars on his talent; a filmography listing basic
information for each film; and finally, the reproduced "Sinatra
Sessions" takes the final quarter of the book's length. So
this book really is a scrapbook, with odds and ends from several
different quarters, and the tone is overall very respectable.
Sprinkled throughout are numerous black and white photos, nothing
remarkable. Overall The Frank Sinatra Scrapbook
a good, solid retrospective with some
nice historic articles thrown in, and the original, hard to find
"Sinatra Sessions" booklet.
Sinatra:
The Entertainer
by Arnold Shaw; Delilah Press,
157 p.
Released February 1, 1984
"Francis
Albert Sinatra long ago left Hoboken, New Jersey, where he spent the
trying, formative years of his life. But Hoboken has never
completely left him. Underneath the surface of the rich,
literate, world-famous man he has become, there linger feelings
generated in him as a lonely, sensitive kid, trying to cope with the
coarse, cobblestone cosmos of the tough, riverside city. In
Hoboken he grew up as an only child, hungering for the affection and
camaraderie of two busy parents; fighting with tough kids for whom his
taste in natty clothes was a challenge and his spindly frame an easy
mark; being beaten up by police who accused him of stealing a new
outfit he wore; and enduring the gives of an uncle and a father who
were trying to teach him the manly art of defense.
[pg. 111]
REVIEW: Whereas
Arnold Shaw's previous Frank bio20th
Century Romantic
was a pleasure to read, The Entertainer,
a later bio, reads as if it
was quickly thrown together, with none of the thoughtfulness
his previous portrait contained, and often sliding into clumsy
metaphors ("coarse cobblestone cosmos?") and rote recitation of fact in
place of insight. Beginning with a description of Sinatra's
40th anniversary celebration as an entertainer on December 8, 1979, the
author gives a quick run-down of Sinatra's life
and accomplishments in the chapters which
follow. "The Singer" and "The Actor" divisions of Sinatra's
career are breezed through, and then, strangely, the author
devotes the next few chapters to specific instances from the 1970s: the
1971 "Retirement Concert" which marked Frank's brief moment out of the
spotlight; an examination of his 1973 "Ol' Blue Eyes Is Back"
return to public performing, and Ronald Reagan's Presidential
Inaguaral on January 19, 1981. In that
sense, this book becomes a magnifying glass to a latter-day
decade of Frank's career, which probably deserves greater investigation
than this book provides - but it's a solid look at this
phase of Sinatra's life, just workmanlike
and uninspired. Perhaps the author doesn't find this
time period worthwhile when compared to his more
fruitful Columbia, Capitol and early Reprise years;
he visibly stuggles with finding appropriate adjectives - or perhaps
his composing powers had faded in the twenty years
between the two books; whatever the reason, Sinatra: The
Entertainer is only a pale shadow of his earlier writing. The
book is filled with photographs, mostly black and white with a color
section in the middle, and the pictures are mostly stock
photos seen in numerous other publications. Generally solid,
but unremarkable.
Sinatra:
In His Own Words
Compiled
by Guy Yarwood; Omnibus Press, 128 p.
Released Feburary 1, 1984
"You
know, I adore making records. I'd rather do that than almost
anything else. You can never do anything in life quite on
your own, you don't live on your own little island. I suppose
you might be able to write a poem or paint a picture entirely on your
own, but I doubt it. I don't think you can ever sing a song
that way, anyway. Yet, in a sort of a paradoxical way, making
a record is as near as you can get to it - although , of
course, the arranger and the orchestra play an enormous part.
But once you're on the record singing, it's you and you
alone. If it's bad and gets criticised, it's you who's to
blame - no one else. If it's good, it's also you.
With a film it's never like that; there are producers and
script-writers and hundreds of men in offices and the thing is taken
right out of your hands. With a record, you're IT.
But I must admit something - I'd never argue with someone like Nelson
on a record date. It's his date, he's the leader."
[pg 51]
REVIEW: In
the absense of a true autobiography from Frank, this book must be
counted as the next best thing, although it's not a
true portrait of his life. In
His Own Words
is part of a whole
series of British books which have
been
released for all kinds of different artists, from the Beatles
to Elton John to the Beach Boys, and the format for all of them is very
much alike: taking quotes from interviews, articles, and appearances,
the editor groups them into sympathetic 'chapters' and simply lets each
celebrity speak for themselves. It's refreshing to read -
since so much of what the public hears about Sinatra is from second-or
third-hand sources. There's not much rhyme nor reason to the
layout, the book begins with a section entitled "Sinatra on Sinatra"
where he discusses himself as he sees it; his thought processes, his
passions, his gifts - little snippets of sound-bites are given where he
ruminates on himself and his habits. Then the book has a
short section where he talks about his begininnings: his parents, his
upbringing, his influences, followed by quotes of Frank discussing his
art - his singing, being with the Harry James and Tommy Dorsey
Orchestras, and his breaking away to forge a solo career.
There are ruminations on the 'bobbysoxers' phenomenon, advice on
singing ("It's like lifting weights. You're conditioning
yourself"), his main influences, including Bing Crosby and
Billie Holliday, he discusses his friendships with Dean Martin and
Sammy Davis Jr., how much he likes women ("I'm very fond of women; I
admire them. But, like all men, I don't understand
them."), and much more. The major failing of this series is
it's reluctance to name sources; each quote is given straight, with no
notation of where or when it was said, which, obviously, can have a
great import into why that particular opinion was
given at the time. So this book cannot be considered a
valuable reference tool, but it serves its purpose as an interesting,
enlightening look into Sinatra's soul.
Frank
Sinatra: My Father
by Nancy Sinatra; Doubleday
(Limited Edition), Paperback Reissue: Hodder & Stoughton
General Division, 388 p.
Released October 1, 1985, Reissued December 1, 1986
"At
various times, because of his loyalty to others or declining to dignify
his attackers, he had sometimes lashed back, but most often he had
subdued his feelings. I had learned, as he had long since,
that to most columnists it's not news that my father can be a nice guy
or that my brother is a decent kid. The many benefactions
didn't start to come out until late in life. Without a
newspaper or a TV station at his command, the only forum open to him,
he thought, was his microphone. So he used it to vent some of
his anger, sometimes humorously, sometimes viciously. He
reached only a few thousand people, whereas the liars reached millions
through their media. But it was a healthy outlet for
him. And for those of us who shared and understood his
plight, each little jab he struck was significant and
understandable. [pg. 267]
REVIEW: Daughter Nancy's
first stab at authoring a book about her father, My Father
swings
wide of the mark of trying to 'set the record straight' and instead
shifts the weight of blame to the other foot, placing all of
the blame on the media, which puts her on the defensive for
most of the book's length - not the most arresting tack for
three-hundred-plus pages. More interesting are the bits of
advice her father would constantly give her, or the small,
private viginettes between her and Frank, which she passes along to the
reader, and which becomes a small window into the soul of
Sinatra. But the majority of the book is really just her
impressions of life in the shadow of her father, seeing from the
inside, but curiously on the outside as well. So if you're
hoping to get an insider's glimpse into Sinatra the man, the father,
the entertainer - you'll be disappointed; this book, while
shying away from being a chronological biography of Frank, is mostly
the musings and observations of Nancy, She discusses Mia
Farrow, Ava Gardner, and her parent's divorce. She
writes about all the celebrities she's met, the kind words spoken to
her by friends of Frank's, and she writes extensively about
her own show-biz career and marriages, particularly about how
the expectations of others was difficult to live up to; everything
she does stays in the gravitational pull of her
father, as her life and successes orbit Frank's unquenchable
career. In that sense, the book reads often like a concession
- Nancy's career is obviously never going to be the flaming
meteor that her father's is, so she simply gives up and climbs onto
Frank's coattails here and goes along for the ride. A good
look at Nancy's life, but only a fragmented look at her
father's.
Frank
Sinatra: A Celebration
by Derek Jewell, with a film
commentary by George Perry; Little, Brown & Company, 192. p.
Released January, 1986
"It
was incontrovertibly those hordes of chemically desperate bobbysoxers
(as they were then called, even though many painted their legs to
simulate stockings) who first uplifted Sinatra. Notice was
given at once of the way things would go. The theatre was
sold out from first show to last for the month Benny Goodman
stayed. Sinatra was retained for another month after that,
and newspapers and magazines were awash with stories attempting to
explain the hysterical effect he had. It was put down to
everything from religious fanaticism to the mothering
instinct. He was frail; he also had a curl on his
forehead. 'Not since the days of Rudolph Valentino has
American womanhood made such unabashed public love to an entertainer,'
said Time magazine, making a similar point to
E.J. Kahn, who would however go back further to Listz and Struass for
his parallels. [pg. 51]
REVIEW:A Celebration
is a
good, literate look at Frank Sinatra, written by British music critic
Derek Jewell, who wrote for the London Sunday Times.
Although he has no firsthand interviews to draw from, his careful
observation of Sinatra, which he claims began in the 1940s, is smart;
he draws information from the best sources, including Arnold Shaw and
the aforementioned E.J. Kahn; and his writing style is impreccable. The
first chapter of the book, entitled "Overture," is all about the
'effect' of Sinatra, and touches on his wide-ranging successes and the
media's continuing fascination with him, even as he was entering his
seventies. The author recounts his own 'conversion' to Sinatra when he
was seventeen years old in 1945, and was entranced by "The Voice" as he
was then known. He remembers watching the news reels of the swooning
'bobbysoxers' and the effect which Sinatra's singing had on women, and
became interested. Then the author deftly begins, in chapter two, to
relay the well-known story of Sinatra's birth and subsequent career,
but writing in a completely fresh, original voice, unlike many of the
other numerous coffee-table books, which are thrown together by writers
with little or no interest in the subject. Jewell is
interested, and is a fine writer, and it makes all the difference in
this photo-biography. Unfortunately for readers, the format of the book
is unfriendly, and even unattractive by modern standards, with
two-column text and photographs making things disjointed, and the
pictures, all in flat black and white, are unappealing on the whole. In
addition to Derek Jewell's contributions to the book, there is also an
extended appendixes containing a separate section devoted to Sinatra's
films, written by George Perry, and which is a straightforward
chronolgy with brief commentary included and lots of photographs.
Sinatra:
An American Classic
By John Rockwell;
Random House/Rolling Stone Press, 255 p.
Released August 24, 1986
"Riddle
was the key to Sinatra's Capitol sound, the model against which all his
other arrangers then and since must be measured. What Riddle
offered was a sure sense of the swing-jazz sound from which Sinatra had
emerged, a subtly masterful command of symphonic scoring, an
understated ability to capture a song's dramatic essence with
intrumental touches, and beyond all that, an irreducible
individuality. His "swinging" records with Sinatra offer
jazzish drive without untoward brassy vulgarity. But where
Riddle comes into his own is with ballads, the lush moodiness rarely
overstated or sentimentalized (as with Stordahl before him and Jenkins
after him) yet all the more moving for its very spareness.
And he was able magically to blend fast and slow, underpinning a ballad
with insinuating rhythmic impetus, thereby combining Sinatra's two main
interpretive inclinations, sexual insouciance and emotional
vulnerability." [pg. 142]
REVIEW: Leave
it to Rolling
Stone to lead the rock 'n' roll revolution which in part put
Sinatra on the back burner in the public's eye, and then produce one of
the finest books about him written during the 1980s. This
oversize coffee-table book, filled with pictures and with a smart,
literate text by John Rockwell (who has a Ph.D. in cultural history),
is a great read, if sometimes a wee bit too smart
for its own good. Mingling rare photographs in both color and
black and white from all eras of Sinatra's career up 'til then, An American Classic
looks great, despite the nauseating purple and pink glittery cover
its saddled with - with several pictures you just won't find anywhere
else, along with large color reproductions of several of his movie and
concert posters, behind the scenes shots, and lots of publicity
photos. The text by John Rockwell is excellent, with
a swiftly-flowing narrative which is never dull, although the author
occasionally gets bogged down in side roads, such as the lengthy
treatise he dives into on Italian Bel Canto
singing, or a later paragraph on narrative songs as American
tradition. As in the case with most Ph.D.'s, I occasionally
get the feeling that he likes using big words just because they make
him sound smart, whereas if Frank Sinatra caught
him talking that way about him, he'd probably label him a gold-plated
windbag. But it's still a great read, with lots of
examinations of the musical structures of certain songs, examinations
of political interplay which Sinatra loved to dally with, and nods to
everything from his romantic entanglements to his film roles, all
written with a depth of understanding which is all too rare in Sinatra
biographies. A surprisingly reverential and well-written
photo-biography which is well worth picking up if you run across it.